Well for me, I think there is no reason for comparison for the two series has its own different types of genre, themes, settings and concept.
Harry Potter series as we all know is categorized as a children's books but for me the book is for all ages. It is more of an adventure than of a love story. Although it is concentrated on the main character which is Harry Potter and we see the story from the character's points of view, it also shows some scenes from the other characters points of view and sometimes scenes that doesn't include Harry Potter himself which frequently happens at the first chapter of the book. The book tackles about the lives, struggles and adventures of Harry Potter. Most of the settings in the story (except book 7) are inside the Hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry.
Twilight saga is categorized as suspense thriller and love story. I think it is more of a love story than of an adventure. The story revolves on one of the main characters which is Isabella Swan and we hear the story all the time from that characters point of view although there is an exception in the last chapter of book 2 and the second part of book 4 which is I think for some obvious reason, when Bella was bed ridden, the author cannot write much about her since Bella is just stationed in one place. The book tackles about the love story of two very different people and the conflicts that it includes. Most of the settings are inside the whole town of Forks and only a few scenes happen inside the school.
But for me the two authors are both excellent writers in their own field. They give justice to their characters and they can really affect your emotions while reading their books. They make you feel like you are the character in that book and you're experiencing the same situations because you can really feel the intensity of their emotions. They give every single thread of details that even you can't describe what its like.
So if you're a kind of reader who likes more of an adventure, then I think you will like Harry Potter series better. And if you are more type of a romance reader who likes more of a love story, then, you will like the Twilight saga better.
So I think it's unfair to compare these two book series and please stop making fuss about it, okay, both the book series are beautiful and are really fun to read.
How about you, which do you think is better, Harry Potter or Twilight?
ไม่มีความคิดเห็น:
แสดงความคิดเห็น